Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
400 lines (360 loc) · 32.5 KB

benchmark_2.0.52.md

File metadata and controls

400 lines (360 loc) · 32.5 KB
Raw

1. EishayFuryCompatibleParse

这个场景是JSONB格式和Fury CompatibleMode反序列化性能比较。基于KeyValue的映射，对增加和删除字段的序列化结构都能有很好的兼容性。

aliyun ecs spec jdk version jsonb fury
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 7362.476 5573.454 (75.7%)
jdk-11.0.20 8116.649 6669.485 (82.17%)
jdk-17.0.8 8583.935 7164.26 (83.46%)
jdk-21.0.2 8773.838 7325.049 (83.49%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 6411.129 3933.978 (61.36%)
jdk-11.0.20 6303.41 3923.715 (62.25%)
jdk-17.0.8 7077.495 4217.839 (59.6%)
jdk-21.0.2 7537.574 4422.852 (58.68%)
graalvm_21+35.1 8825.448 5106.524 (57.86%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 7912.216 7172.333 (90.65%)
jdk-11.0.20 8584.327 6742.16 (78.54%)
jdk-17.0.8 9493.432 6921.613 (72.91%)
jdk-21.0.2 9302.376 7422.175 (79.79%)
graalvm_21+35.1 11280.573 8324.447 (73.79%)

2. EishayFuryCompatibleWrite

这个场景是JSONB格式和Fury CompatibleMode序列化性能比较。基于KeyValue的映射，对增加和删除字段的序列化结构都能有很好的兼容性。

aliyun ecs spec jdk version jsonb fury
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 6476.378 6197.591 (95.7%)
jdk-11.0.20 7001.457 6151.085 (87.85%)
jdk-17.0.8 8172.959 7400.699 (90.55%)
jdk-21.0.2 8292.222 7079.804 (85.38%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 4546.203 3920.802 (86.24%)
jdk-11.0.20 4418.367 3999.063 (90.51%)
jdk-17.0.8 4292.057 4869.554 (113.46%)
jdk-21.0.2 5172.866 4192.646 (81.05%)
graalvm_21+35.1 6227.203 4202.971 (67.49%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 6959.747 6612.734 (95.01%)
jdk-11.0.20 7787.731 6764.044 (86.86%)
jdk-17.0.8 7635.17 6836.71 (89.54%)
jdk-21.0.2 8233.43 6018.228 (73.1%)
graalvm_21+35.1 10005.064 6154.037 (61.51%)

3. EishayParseBinary

这个场景是二进制反序列化比较，JSONB格式、JSON UTF8编码(fastjson2UTF8Bytes)、hessian、javaSerialize的比较，用于Apache dubbo的用户选择二进制协议比较

aliyun ecs spec jdk version jsonb fastjson2UTF8Bytes hessian javaSerialize
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 8368.822 4423.505 (52.86%) 838.533 (10.02%) 144.412 (1.73%)
jdk-11.0.20 9388.647 4869.396 (51.86%) 777.585 (8.28%) 152.67 (1.63%)
jdk-17.0.8 10348.858 5100.895 (49.29%) 778.812 (7.53%) 167.902 (1.62%)
jdk-21.0.2 10282.685 5262.424 (51.18%) 802.646 (7.81%) 153.244 (1.49%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 7520.642 3494.026 (46.46%) 671.441 (8.93%) 112.816 (1.5%)
jdk-11.0.20 7313.457 3516.879 (48.09%) 627.245 (8.58%) 114.746 (1.57%)
jdk-17.0.8 8939.133 3889.537 (43.51%) 627.603 (7.02%) 128.881 (1.44%)
jdk-21.0.2 9299.26 3940.112 (42.37%) 678.949 (7.3%) 124.977 (1.34%)
graalvm_21+35.1 9914.726 4134.858 (41.7%) 801.001 (8.08%) 122.548 (1.24%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 8941.397 5315.798 (59.45%) 371.49 (4.15%) 179.992 (2.01%)
jdk-11.0.20 9309.87 5589.358 (60.04%) 421.767 (4.53%) 174.749 (1.88%)
jdk-17.0.8 10040.161 5539.031 (55.17%) 414.473 (4.13%) 170.541 (1.7%)
jdk-21.0.2 10091.787 5454.862 (54.05%) 489.914 (4.85%) 176.92 (1.75%)
graalvm_21+35.1 12281.414 5933.002 (48.31%) 684.352 (5.57%) 178.66 (1.45%)

4. EishayParseBinaryArrayMapping

这个场景是二进制反序列化比较，JSONB格式（基于字段顺序映射）、kryo、protobuf的比较

aliyun ecs spec jdk version jsonb kryo protobuf
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 10703.936 4698.773 (43.9%) 3981.339 (37.2%)
jdk-11.0.20 12604.044 4561.522 (36.19%) 4471.276 (35.47%)
jdk-17.0.8 13851.94 4499.917 (32.49%) 5903.813 (42.62%)
jdk-21.0.2 13476.356 4585.56 (34.03%) 5921.166 (43.94%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 10199.763 3347.64 (32.82%) 3164.429 (31.02%)
jdk-11.0.20 9934.802 3393.87 (34.16%) 2846.877 (28.66%)
jdk-17.0.8 13480.1 3211.863 (23.83%) 3752.016 (27.83%)
jdk-21.0.2 13020.943 3569.105 (27.41%) 3659.429 (28.1%)
graalvm_21+35.1 17166.782 3918.99 (22.83%) 5403.772 (31.48%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 11625.676 4769.184 (41.02%) 3838.382 (33.02%)
jdk-11.0.20 11125.867 5769.948 (51.86%) 3940.216 (35.41%)
jdk-17.0.8 12238.985 5945.738 (48.58%) 4710.357 (38.49%)
jdk-21.0.2 12441.946 5515.556 (44.33%) 5037.745 (40.49%)
graalvm_21+35.1 21242.683 5222.607 (24.59%) 7605.491 (35.8%)

5. EishayParseBinaryAutoType

这个场景是带类型信息二进制反序列化比较，JSONB格式、JSON UTF8编码(fastjson2UTF8Bytes)、hessian、javaSerialize的比较，用于Apache dubbo的用户选择二进制协议比较

aliyun ecs spec jdk version fastjson2JSONB hessian javaSerialize
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 5038.214 865.862 (17.19%) 144.965 (2.88%)
jdk-11.0.20 4923.747 770.387 (15.65%) 145.118 (2.95%)
jdk-17.0.8 5825.125 809.16 (13.89%) 167.322 (2.87%)
jdk-21.0.2 5754.128 809.789 (14.07%) 153.742 (2.67%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 4360.669 664.032 (15.23%) 114.065 (2.62%)
jdk-11.0.20 4254.165 625.105 (14.69%) 113.778 (2.67%)
jdk-17.0.8 4730.133 656.116 (13.87%) 128.182 (2.71%)
jdk-21.0.2 4784.683 684.556 (14.31%) 124.671 (2.61%)
graalvm_21+35.1 5395.139 860.982 (15.96%) 128.002 (2.37%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 5614.084 399.413 (7.11%) 179.271 (3.19%)
jdk-11.0.20 2780.438 475.177 (17.09%) 167.821 (6.04%)
jdk-17.0.8 6243.021 404.961 (6.49%) 172.962 (2.77%)
jdk-21.0.2 6034.652 564.528 (9.35%) 179.514 (2.97%)
graalvm_21+35.1 7276.946 743.648 (10.22%) 179.842 (2.47%)

6. EishayParseString

这个场景是将没有格式化的JSON字符串反序列化为JavaBean对象，是最常用的场景，这个是fastjson1的强项。

aliyun ecs spec jdk version fastjson2 fastjson1 jackson gson
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 4325.51 3234.663 (74.78%) 1446.789 (33.45%) 1303.781 (30.14%)
jdk-11.0.20 4842.006 2811.713 (58.07%) 1353.053 (27.94%) 1329.69 (27.46%)
jdk-17.0.8 5069.906 4049.875 (79.88%) 1444.006 (28.48%) 1355.3 (26.73%)
jdk-21.0.2 5279.801 3796.647 (71.91%) 1341.899 (25.42%) 1229.955 (23.3%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 3192.818 2199.511 (68.89%) 1026.4 (32.15%) 989.975 (31.01%)
jdk-11.0.20 3515.317 1953.133 (55.56%) 979.236 (27.86%) 963.342 (27.4%)
jdk-17.0.8 3793.149 2579.187 (68%) 964.943 (25.44%) 917.957 (24.2%)
jdk-21.0.2 3842.258 2619.447 (68.17%) 972.11 (25.3%) 923.561 (24.04%)
graalvm_21+35.1 3911.585 3626.257 (92.71%) 1077.906 (27.56%) 1026.775 (26.25%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 5193.746 3369.906 (64.88%) 1474.771 (28.4%) 1562.467 (30.08%)
jdk-11.0.20 5671.485 3281.483 (57.86%) 1389.277 (24.5%) 1495.173 (26.36%)
jdk-17.0.8 5695.815 4374.742 (76.81%) 1475.76 (25.91%) 1528.884 (26.84%)
jdk-21.0.2 5596.734 4407.789 (78.76%) 1396.419 (24.95%) 1378.897 (24.64%)
graalvm_21+35.1 6062.05 5042.226 (83.18%) 1473.758 (24.31%) 1380.095 (22.77%)

7. EishayParseStringPretty

这个场景是将格式化过的JSON字符串反序列化为JavaBean对象

aliyun ecs spec jdk version fastjson2 fastjson1 jackson gson
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 2921.474 893.923 (30.6%) 1347.343 (46.12%) 1219.417 (41.74%)
jdk-11.0.20 2835.815 764.332 (26.95%) 1270.213 (44.79%) 1248.898 (44.04%)
jdk-17.0.8 3702.275 948.841 (25.63%) 1296.266 (35.01%) 1308.077 (35.33%)
jdk-21.0.2 3934.589 904.776 (23%) 1269.19 (32.26%) 1178.483 (29.95%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 2124.69 587.133 (27.63%) 975.876 (45.93%) 898.474 (42.29%)
jdk-11.0.20 2106.438 574.649 (27.28%) 899.485 (42.7%) 889.41 (42.22%)
jdk-17.0.8 2539.157 627.557 (24.72%) 895.696 (35.28%) 927.149 (36.51%)
jdk-21.0.2 2660.933 632.427 (23.77%) 920.511 (34.59%) 890.455 (33.46%)
graalvm_21+35.1 2408.319 881.721 (36.61%) 956.865 (39.73%) 945.782 (39.27%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 1923.824 955.791 (49.68%) 1360.556 (70.72%) 1418.923 (73.76%)
jdk-11.0.20 4187.211 990.382 (23.65%) 1352.962 (32.31%) 1405.211 (33.56%)
jdk-17.0.8 4121.924 1099.114 (26.67%) 1371.494 (33.27%) 1379.566 (33.47%)
jdk-21.0.2 4094.297 1001.451 (24.46%) 1327.264 (32.42%) 1243.314 (30.37%)
graalvm_21+35.1 4425.865 1379.193 (31.16%) 1368.558 (30.92%) 1309.296 (29.58%)

8. EishayParseTreeString

这个场景是将没有格式化的JSON字符串解析为JSONObject或者HashMap，不涉及绑定JavaBean对象。

aliyun ecs spec jdk version fastjson2 fastjson1 jackson gson
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 2687.806 1556.311 (57.9%) 1505.656 (56.02%) 1136.2 (42.27%)
jdk-11.0.20 2270.188 1160.947 (51.14%) 1362.856 (60.03%) 1117.136 (49.21%)
jdk-17.0.8 2781.905 1554.543 (55.88%) 1581.79 (56.86%) 1161.59 (41.76%)
jdk-21.0.2 2821.885 1448.236 (51.32%) 1578.271 (55.93%) 1123.614 (39.82%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 1952.001 1138.311 (58.32%) 1178.707 (60.38%) 825.917 (42.31%)
jdk-11.0.20 1796.483 1020.569 (56.81%) 930.95 (51.82%) 810.249 (45.1%)
jdk-17.0.8 2291.86 1268.298 (55.34%) 1117.128 (48.74%) 793.963 (34.64%)
jdk-21.0.2 2374.445 1193.931 (50.28%) 1132.328 (47.69%) 766.479 (32.28%)
graalvm_21+35.1 2222.76 1514.417 (68.13%) 1147.897 (51.64%) 957.097 (43.06%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 2755.432 1257.944 (45.65%) 1343.066 (48.74%) 1246.832 (45.25%)
jdk-11.0.20 3104.218 1499.793 (48.31%) 1313.741 (42.32%) 1183.955 (38.14%)
jdk-17.0.8 3051.016 1573.012 (51.56%) 1396.566 (45.77%) 1219.841 (39.98%)
jdk-21.0.2 3126.853 1480.904 (47.36%) 1341.276 (42.9%) 1161.224 (37.14%)
graalvm_21+35.1 3236.006 2253.502 (69.64%) 1674.497 (51.75%) 1448.39 (44.76%)

9. EishayParseTreeStringPretty

这个场景是将格式化过的字符串解析为JSONObject或者HashMap，不涉及绑定JavaBean对象。

aliyun ecs spec jdk version fastjson2 fastjson1 jackson gson
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 2293.14 1362.152 (59.4%) 1419.876 (61.92%) 1089.682 (47.52%)
jdk-11.0.20 2020.493 998.965 (49.44%) 1269.299 (62.82%) 1070.433 (52.98%)
jdk-17.0.8 2308.086 1364.165 (59.1%) 1466.844 (63.55%) 1077.877 (46.7%)
jdk-21.0.2 2303.214 1292.235 (56.11%) 1498.931 (65.08%) 1068.46 (46.39%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 1453.169 968.076 (66.62%) 1073.744 (73.89%) 792.516 (54.54%)
jdk-11.0.20 1505.201 858.963 (57.07%) 896.3 (59.55%) 727.291 (48.32%)
jdk-17.0.8 1725.632 1080.616 (62.62%) 982.125 (56.91%) 741.531 (42.97%)
jdk-21.0.2 1835.449 1020.474 (55.6%) 994.3 (54.17%) 745.77 (40.63%)
graalvm_21+35.1 1539.652 1304.474 (84.73%) 1080.056 (70.15%) 874.078 (56.77%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 2393.592 1183.532 (49.45%) 1203.009 (50.26%) 1180.195 (49.31%)
jdk-11.0.20 2621.148 1322.345 (50.45%) 1253.633 (47.83%) 1129.879 (43.11%)
jdk-17.0.8 2576.676 1432.526 (55.6%) 1289.647 (50.05%) 1160.113 (45.02%)
jdk-21.0.2 2513.229 1307.232 (52.01%) 1326.981 (52.8%) 1049.158 (41.75%)
graalvm_21+35.1 2699.262 1975.665 (73.19%) 1528.98 (56.64%) 1269.002 (47.01%)

10. EishayParseTreeUTF8Bytes

这个场景是将没有格式化的JSON字符串UTF8编码的byte[]数组反序列化解析为JSONObject或者HashMap，不涉及绑定JavaBean对象。

aliyun ecs spec jdk version fastjson2 fastjson1 jackson gson
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 2584.695 1338.472 (51.78%) 1845.494 (71.4%) 1028.391 (39.79%)
jdk-11.0.20 2316.008 1029.204 (44.44%) 1544.732 (66.7%) 1114.422 (48.12%)
jdk-17.0.8 2798.647 1349.177 (48.21%) 1678.152 (59.96%) 1135.839 (40.59%)
jdk-21.0.2 2902.293 1312.974 (45.24%) 1704.114 (58.72%) 1077.456 (37.12%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 2125.341 1046.688 (49.25%) 1252.666 (58.94%) 796.302 (37.47%)
jdk-11.0.20 1864.528 910.33 (48.82%) 1169.197 (62.71%) 787.183 (42.22%)
jdk-17.0.8 2363.126 1105.44 (46.78%) 1179.326 (49.91%) 769.044 (32.54%)
jdk-21.0.2 2456.221 1048.789 (42.7%) 1202.165 (48.94%) 768.39 (31.28%)
graalvm_21+35.1 2248.924 1374.247 (61.11%) 1314.45 (58.45%) 939.452 (41.77%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 2832.39 1295.969 (45.76%) 1380.082 (48.72%) 1127.722 (39.82%)
jdk-11.0.20 3099.513 1333.477 (43.02%) 1489.807 (48.07%) 1125.425 (36.31%)
jdk-17.0.8 2984.846 1436.885 (48.14%) 1592.408 (53.35%) 1173.097 (39.3%)
jdk-21.0.2 2991.274 1315.668 (43.98%) 1553.179 (51.92%) 1128.229 (37.72%)
graalvm_21+35.1 3422.15 1873.114 (54.74%) 1711.812 (50.02%) 1341.227 (39.19%)

11. EishayParseTreeUTF8BytesPretty

这个场景是将格式化过的字符串UTF8编码的byte[]数组反序列化解析为JSONObject或者HashMap，不涉及绑定JavaBean对象。

aliyun ecs spec jdk version fastjson2 fastjson1 jackson gson
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 2111.633 1150.475 (54.48%) 1535.595 (72.72%) 955.771 (45.26%)
jdk-11.0.20 2059.891 877.284 (42.59%) 1466.998 (71.22%) 1027.245 (49.87%)
jdk-17.0.8 2354.983 1157.977 (49.17%) 1591.031 (67.56%) 1043.364 (44.3%)
jdk-21.0.2 2345.424 1164.341 (49.64%) 1550.936 (66.13%) 1032.144 (44.01%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 1503.728 882.762 (58.7%) 1104.902 (73.48%) 707.255 (47.03%)
jdk-11.0.20 1467.223 797.422 (54.35%) 1013.93 (69.11%) 723.484 (49.31%)
jdk-17.0.8 1777.162 933.011 (52.5%) 1070.829 (60.26%) 721.924 (40.62%)
jdk-21.0.2 1830.378 888.346 (48.53%) 1094.449 (59.79%) 734.77 (40.14%)
graalvm_21+35.1 1552.25 1040.887 (67.06%) 1094.136 (70.49%) 846.364 (54.52%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 2430.867 1094.794 (45.04%) 1268.611 (52.19%) 1064.074 (43.77%)
jdk-11.0.20 2582.449 1131.717 (43.82%) 1402.263 (54.3%) 1093.394 (42.34%)
jdk-17.0.8 2514.636 1227.35 (48.81%) 1489.415 (59.23%) 1123.683 (44.69%)
jdk-21.0.2 2475.164 1166.413 (47.12%) 1469.939 (59.39%) 1031.411 (41.67%)
graalvm_21+35.1 2819.965 1489.161 (52.81%) 1524.289 (54.05%) 1330.655 (47.19%)

12. EishayParseUTF8Bytes

这个场景是将没有格式化的JSON字符串UTF8编码的byte[]数组反序列化为JavaBean对象，是最常用的场景，这个是fastjson1的强项。

aliyun ecs spec jdk version fastjson2 fastjson1 jackson gson
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 3147.525 2523.418 (80.17%) 1659.986 (52.74%) 1161.565 (36.9%)
jdk-11.0.20 3618.094 2228.472 (61.59%) 1532.069 (42.34%) 1305.032 (36.07%)
jdk-17.0.8 5237.092 2796.117 (53.39%) 1581.509 (30.2%) 1371.843 (26.19%)
jdk-21.0.2 5283.21 2729.409 (51.66%) 1525.245 (28.87%) 1156.48 (21.89%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 3472.499 1887.659 (54.36%) 1168.527 (33.65%) 944.235 (27.19%)
jdk-11.0.20 1959.456 1681.015 (85.79%) 1061.744 (54.19%) 965.983 (49.3%)
jdk-17.0.8 3867.207 1953.027 (50.5%) 1094.044 (28.29%) 991.5 (25.64%)
jdk-21.0.2 3947.632 2143.097 (54.29%) 1101.204 (27.9%) 912.186 (23.11%)
graalvm_21+35.1 4229.0 2614.983 (61.83%) 1130.589 (26.73%) 1020.29 (24.13%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 2002.317 2825.912 (141.13%) 1689.712 (84.39%) 1425.643 (71.2%)
jdk-11.0.20 2174.702 2654.124 (122.05%) 1556.213 (71.56%) 1403.846 (64.55%)
jdk-17.0.8 5520.993 3517.895 (63.72%) 1678.727 (30.41%) 1525.43 (27.63%)
jdk-21.0.2 5753.452 3482.648 (60.53%) 1577.317 (27.42%) 1379.962 (23.98%)
graalvm_21+35.1 5877.27 3417.528 (58.15%) 1501.348 (25.54%) 1328.557 (22.61%)

13. EishayParseUTF8BytesPretty

这个场景是将格式化过的JSON字符串UTF8编码的byte[]数组反序列化为JavaBean对象

aliyun ecs spec jdk version fastjson2 fastjson1 jackson gson
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 3342.615 800.341 (23.94%) 1542.776 (46.15%) 943.954 (28.24%)
jdk-11.0.20 3314.678 695.151 (20.97%) 1391.666 (41.98%) 1025.432 (30.94%)
jdk-17.0.8 3788.472 829.839 (21.9%) 1494.852 (39.46%) 1045.077 (27.59%)
jdk-21.0.2 4048.687 808.573 (19.97%) 1372.314 (33.9%) 1024.125 (25.3%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 1757.338 549.55 (31.27%) 1056.915 (60.14%) 741.902 (42.22%)
jdk-11.0.20 2372.535 536.612 (22.62%) 997.709 (42.05%) 708.764 (29.87%)
jdk-17.0.8 2502.897 574.342 (22.95%) 992.852 (39.67%) 720.066 (28.77%)
jdk-21.0.2 2729.453 590.181 (21.62%) 977.341 (35.81%) 711.285 (26.06%)
graalvm_21+35.1 2404.522 806.339 (33.53%) 1000.847 (41.62%) 901.649 (37.5%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 3987.535 914.801 (22.94%) 1548.571 (38.84%) 990.915 (24.85%)
jdk-11.0.20 4114.179 895.035 (21.75%) 1462.884 (35.56%) 1085.304 (26.38%)
jdk-17.0.8 4160.973 984.584 (23.66%) 1456.397 (35%) 1098.999 (26.41%)
jdk-21.0.2 4126.588 926.772 (22.46%) 1470.21 (35.63%) 1074.07 (26.03%)
graalvm_21+35.1 4505.277 1155.94 (25.66%) 1339.23 (29.73%) 1350.098 (29.97%)

14. EishayWriteBinary

这个场景是二进制序列化比较，JSONB格式、JSON UTF8编码(fastjson2UTF8Bytes)、hessian、javaSerialize的比较，用于Apache dubbo的用户选择二进制协议比较

aliyun ecs spec jdk version jsonb msgpack protobuf
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 9673.885 1119.75 (11.57%) 4494.908 (46.46%)
jdk-11.0.20 11697.632 1545.053 (13.21%) 4159.996 (35.56%)
jdk-17.0.8 15095.083 1699.602 (11.26%) 5786.625 (38.33%)
jdk-21.0.2 15008.899 1571.821 (10.47%) 6039.433 (40.24%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 8660.254 992.612 (11.46%) 3437.071 (39.69%)
jdk-11.0.20 8319.371 1245.868 (14.98%) 2909.669 (34.97%)
jdk-17.0.8 10782.993 1406.229 (13.04%) 3362.476 (31.18%)
jdk-21.0.2 9860.437 1306.788 (13.25%) 3361.174 (34.09%)
graalvm_21+35.1 12147.787 1405.701 (11.57%) 7162.217 (58.96%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 10225.443 1289.487 (12.61%) 3952.013 (38.65%)
jdk-11.0.20 12177.715 1790.513 (14.7%) 4000.052 (32.85%)
jdk-17.0.8 14282.461 1885.547 (13.2%) 5251.565 (36.77%)
jdk-21.0.2 11902.348 1831.382 (15.39%) 5330.129 (44.78%)
graalvm_21+35.1 17657.235 1782.629 (10.1%) 9657.414 (54.69%)

15. EishayWriteBinaryArrayMapping

这个场景是二进制序列化比较，JSONB格式（基于字段顺序映射）、kryo、protobuf的比较

aliyun ecs spec jdk version jsonb kryo protobuf
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 11947.932 5192.163 (43.46%) 5019.273 (42.01%)
jdk-11.0.20 17942.223 5176.296 (28.85%) 5239.336 (29.2%)
jdk-17.0.8 20449.931 5490.58 (26.85%) 5589.868 (27.33%)
jdk-21.0.2 19768.851 5466.33 (27.65%) 6057.56 (30.64%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 9917.752 3873.118 (39.05%) 3143.725 (31.7%)
jdk-11.0.20 13810.635 3490.666 (25.28%) 3535.338 (25.6%)
jdk-17.0.8 14615.995 4317.643 (29.54%) 3580.267 (24.5%)
jdk-21.0.2 17514.858 4217.713 (24.08%) 3454.125 (19.72%)
graalvm_21+35.1 13361.585 5571.318 (41.7%) 7284.551 (54.52%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 9516.714 5500.538 (57.8%) 3964.3 (41.66%)
jdk-11.0.20 17480.241 5266.982 (30.13%) 5787.151 (33.11%)
jdk-17.0.8 14545.204 6518.122 (44.81%) 4949.618 (34.03%)
jdk-21.0.2 19457.999 6401.859 (32.9%) 5335.708 (27.42%)
graalvm_21+35.1 25982.335 7398.107 (28.47%) 10375.057 (39.93%)

16. EishayWriteBinaryAutoType

这个场景是带类型信息二进制序列化比较，JSONB格式、JSON UTF8编码(fastjson2UTF8Bytes)、hessian、javaSerialize的比较，用于Apache dubbo的用户选择二进制协议比较

aliyun ecs spec jdk version fastjson2JSONB hessian javaSerialize
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 3595.255 1356.384 (37.73%) 774.067 (21.53%)
jdk-11.0.20 3740.454 1255.222 (33.56%) 759.94 (20.32%)
jdk-17.0.8 4719.779 1229.321 (26.05%) 786.746 (16.67%)
jdk-21.0.2 4133.707 1296.515 (31.36%) 788.215 (19.07%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 2806.944 878.567 (31.3%) 531.576 (18.94%)
jdk-11.0.20 2543.125 825.59 (32.46%) 506.81 (19.93%)
jdk-17.0.8 2988.839 802.596 (26.85%) 544.516 (18.22%)
jdk-21.0.2 3016.289 817.972 (27.12%) 550.152 (18.24%)
graalvm_21+35.1 2792.069 1163.345 (41.67%) 542.845 (19.44%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 4335.516 1214.546 (28.01%) 868.294 (20.03%)
jdk-11.0.20 4426.325 1045.154 (23.61%) 963.755 (21.77%)
jdk-17.0.8 4416.019 1294.38 (29.31%) 873.617 (19.78%)
jdk-21.0.2 4714.6 1276.054 (27.07%) 932.961 (19.79%)
graalvm_21+35.1 4933.836 1304.31 (26.44%) 885.075 (17.94%)

17. EishayWriteString

这个场景是将JavaBean对象序列化为字符串

aliyun ecs spec jdk version fastjson2 fastjson1 jackson gson
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 6041.398 1894.253 (31.35%) 2441.811 (40.42%) 1295.481 (21.44%)
jdk-11.0.20 6247.467 1786.661 (28.6%) 2479.508 (39.69%) 857.263 (13.72%)
jdk-17.0.8 6700.211 1992.823 (29.74%) 2732.272 (40.78%) 1152.022 (17.19%)
jdk-21.0.2 6964.859 1917.75 (27.53%) 2450.915 (35.19%) 1072.381 (15.4%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 4353.482 1557.451 (35.77%) 2130.477 (48.94%) 948.149 (21.78%)
jdk-11.0.20 4049.01 1428.421 (35.28%) 1917.63 (47.36%) 798.525 (19.72%)
jdk-17.0.8 4330.529 1487.523 (34.35%) 2047.48 (47.28%) 701.589 (16.2%)
jdk-21.0.2 4743.902 1928.679 (40.66%) 1907.71 (40.21%) 686.798 (14.48%)
graalvm_21+35.1 6319.762 1742.473 (27.57%) 2152.451 (34.06%) 643.746 (10.19%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 5589.642 2176.766 (38.94%) 2722.878 (48.71%) 1522.36 (27.24%)
jdk-11.0.20 6361.747 2049.867 (32.22%) 2675.049 (42.05%) 1199.717 (18.86%)
jdk-17.0.8 6376.831 2137.64 (33.52%) 2907.451 (45.59%) 920.825 (14.44%)
jdk-21.0.2 6572.096 2039.59 (31.03%) 2662.801 (40.52%) 855.198 (13.01%)
graalvm_21+35.1 8816.301 2803.644 (31.8%) 3022.123 (34.28%) 840.046 (9.53%)

18. EishayWriteStringTree

这个场景是将JSONObject或者Map序列化为字符串

aliyun ecs spec jdk version fastjson2 fastjson1 jackson gson
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 4005.776 2382.583 (59.48%) 2443.404 (61%) 1382.538 (34.51%)
jdk-11.0.20 2844.374 2288.941 (80.47%) 2517.317 (88.5%) 974.497 (34.26%)
jdk-17.0.8 4123.756 2159.845 (52.38%) 2575.816 (62.46%) 1228.921 (29.8%)
jdk-21.0.2 3903.824 2324.467 (59.54%) 2487.28 (63.71%) 1228.66 (31.47%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 3512.157 2056.203 (58.55%) 1907.41 (54.31%) 1083.749 (30.86%)
jdk-11.0.20 2504.221 1774.456 (70.86%) 1957.78 (78.18%) 706.248 (28.2%)
jdk-17.0.8 3238.289 1797.378 (55.5%) 1839.667 (56.81%) 735.164 (22.7%)
jdk-21.0.2 3446.616 1814.665 (52.65%) 1945.937 (56.46%) 729.571 (21.17%)
graalvm_21+35.1 3415.7 1688.97 (49.45%) 1947.288 (57.01%) 687.887 (20.14%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 3793.039 2481.139 (65.41%) 2794.639 (73.68%) 1703.025 (44.9%)
jdk-11.0.20 3963.227 2600.888 (65.63%) 2859.988 (72.16%) 1366.488 (34.48%)
jdk-17.0.8 5108.773 2613.907 (51.17%) 2608.162 (51.05%) 934.186 (18.29%)
jdk-21.0.2 4974.389 2600.096 (52.27%) 2696.097 (54.2%) 962.337 (19.35%)
graalvm_21+35.1 5302.479 3120.453 (58.85%) 3268.853 (61.65%) 910.44 (17.17%)

19. EishayWriteUTF8Bytes

这个场景是将JavaBean对象序列化为UTF8编码的Bytes

aliyun ecs spec jdk version fastjson2 fastjson1 jackson gson
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 5542.939 1756.013 (31.68%) 2263.805 (40.84%) 1163.033 (20.98%)
jdk-11.0.20 6458.061 2123.597 (32.88%) 2395.026 (37.09%) 902.089 (13.97%)
jdk-17.0.8 7328.996 1676.014 (22.87%) 2562.956 (34.97%) 1081.508 (14.76%)
jdk-21.0.2 7529.458 1650.322 (21.92%) 2458.991 (32.66%) 1076.077 (14.29%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 3803.862 1400.561 (36.82%) 2006.209 (52.74%) 893.399 (23.49%)
jdk-11.0.20 4409.686 1275.596 (28.93%) 1806.725 (40.97%) 696.315 (15.79%)
jdk-17.0.8 4910.394 1294.541 (26.36%) 1973.351 (40.19%) 693.395 (14.12%)
jdk-21.0.2 5090.986 1402.298 (27.54%) 2198.058 (43.18%) 690.496 (13.56%)
graalvm_21+35.1 5697.936 1522.701 (26.72%) 2603.085 (45.68%) 641.265 (11.25%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 6344.282 2134.93 (33.65%) 2841.958 (44.8%) 1316.452 (20.75%)
jdk-11.0.20 6315.113 2521.402 (39.93%) 2573.673 (40.75%) 1198.397 (18.98%)
jdk-17.0.8 6587.5 2147.744 (32.6%) 2836.039 (43.05%) 876.889 (13.31%)
jdk-21.0.2 7048.3 1846.057 (26.19%) 2683.851 (38.08%) 891.238 (12.64%)
graalvm_21+35.1 8402.605 2246.969 (26.74%) 3003.523 (35.75%) 832.399 (9.91%)

20. EishayWriteUTF8BytesTree

这个场景是将JSONObject或者Map序列化为UTF8编码的Bytes

aliyun ecs spec jdk version fastjson2 jackson
aliyun_ecs.c8a.large jdk1.8.0_381 4275.521 2520.288 (58.95%)
jdk-11.0.20 3711.239 1989.281 (53.6%)
jdk-17.0.8 4150.637 2300.846 (55.43%)
jdk-21.0.2 4269.537 2522.322 (59.08%)
aliyun_ecs.c8i.large jdk1.8.0_381 3719.359 1982.327 (53.3%)
jdk-11.0.20 2976.217 1731.505 (58.18%)
jdk-17.0.8 3849.578 1687.065 (43.82%)
jdk-21.0.2 3455.727 2032.772 (58.82%)
graalvm_21+35.1 4200.401 2171.36 (51.69%)
aliyun_ecs.c8y.large jdk1.8.0_381 4679.332 3092.69 (66.09%)
jdk-11.0.20 5105.974 2342.436 (45.88%)
jdk-17.0.8 4993.808 2848.273 (57.04%)
jdk-21.0.2 5603.704 2837.307 (50.63%)
graalvm_21+35.1 5331.304 3542.348 (66.44%)