"info":{"error":"Fee calculation not supported for 9190#westend"}

[lcovar]

Description

Polkadot v0.9.18
substrate-api-sidecar v11.3.16

Fees not calculate for westend transactions.

Block Example
blocks/10481441

{
  "number": "10481441",
  "hash": "0xcead389ee2e4a75c638daf2daa3b167343b850a67fe1835e34b3ccd14fe87914",
  "parentHash": "0x222f2b9be4ea0b6f42a2c1bdc124c52384a26ebf18384597b9bff739b54eabb2",
  "stateRoot": "0x8de408501568f1f232e2804ed6695c766fd08c8b553a4037794fabf6de015cf6",
  "extrinsicsRoot": "0x4295c355faab7120db43ba7edeab45e4cbf174212efd68abea8f3b4fe267a4cf",
  "authorId": "5Ft3J6iqSQPWX2S9jERXcMpevt8JDUPWjec5uGierfVGXisE",
  "logs": [
    {
      "type": "PreRuntime",
      "index": "6",
      "value": [
        "0x42414245",
        "0x030b000000b31e651000000000b61885a4583fe8be225de18e55b239ede42cbc600e52af249149673fc3ca19352106fe4887d2af5185bf550cbe83744134a00112a9a12142ccef8b273c0bf40763c69dc44ccdbaee9ea10d5e77368c509437ad7551111f4fd9edc85f0b36c80f"
      ]
    },
    {
      "type": "Seal",
      "index": "5",
      "value": [
        "0x42414245",
        "0x3e27b9a1e300c366daeda94ae50e97885249f45e7b584f355f01e265fc3bd95113dad2ba513955d91e379a4b75bd52cbdd15d245495a2624e522d2f040303d84"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "onInitialize": {
    "events": []
  },
  "extrinsics": [
    {
      "method": {
        "pallet": "timestamp",
        "method": "set"
      },
      "signature": null,
      "nonce": null,
      "args": {
        "now": "1650374706004"
      },
      "tip": null,
      "hash": "0xacdec955f92601b24e6082abd094b35203b753d4a0f10953be1a2e427b6c896f",
      "info": {},
      "era": {
        "immortalEra": "0x00"
      },
      "events": [
        {
          "method": {
            "pallet": "system",
            "method": "ExtrinsicSuccess"
          },
          "data": [
            {
              "weight": "154704000",
              "class": "Mandatory",
              "paysFee": "Yes"
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "success": true,
      "paysFee": false
    },
    {
      "method": {
        "pallet": "paraInherent",
        "method": "enter"
      },
      "signature": null,
      "nonce": null,
      "args": {
        "data": {
          "bitfields": [
            {
              "payload": "0x01",
              "validatorIndex": "0",
              "signature": "0x62489d4efca49ff3ef08602d8ba6afdd4d80db39fe74d83f9a5e7b01bb968c3201f9c06e30401bff9cd0554babe92c96e0146f69e0824c31e21196e90dcf4883"
            },
            {
              "payload": "0x01",
              "validatorIndex": "1",
              "signature": "0xb290d3b5b3cd86f2702bd713a8d04405f4af65bc736e4e80428e1ac2008fc45c366f95ae7be8a5f947159f23f25b70c39ba8492009e494bc5e17b070cd635e81"
            },
            {
              "payload": "0x01",
              "validatorIndex": "2",
              "signature": "0x168406625ac56a8ec9bac023a3100a9b9b0a15b82f7dd67f9f08ab48708dff5259f9a5003ed2b6ea912a1ce087d4d6b84a54c7a68d86fe2364b1e8e3ea2d7389"
            },
            {
              "payload": "0x01",
              "validatorIndex": "3",
              "signature": "0x488595245a3664b790b1bc53604d9c73078c6be8dede6d1df65726620439ee5572694188e9e631380eda5e6f7b76b172e57f71a643902b77763c63572b7e018e"
            },
            {
              "payload": "0x01",
              "validatorIndex": "4",
              "signature": "0x7c59e017f3e159c033809cd10a087a78197960bc9f5363a8637fd391c9c8a71da308dc835193aa8b116e9e31479d94a7c61aa8dddb7debe420fe81ee8c14ad8a"
            },
            {
              "payload": "0x01",
              "validatorIndex": "5",
              "signature": "0xda96a53095efcff7b2bb4959409ba14baa0b776177b7a70cc566d6cbc8e807101550a754ff7fd7906026d4d451b0b10acbedcbe263a4ef308c99bc5763581681"
            },
            {
              "payload": "0x01",
              "validatorIndex": "6",
              "signature": "0x1cb73a7480a2457e6c4d5b890eb3973ff17687bd130194ee49c1b83a25247545c197cd9728ad2e7e709bd7e044017ecddc16619ab00e0f74de60d36d0eb27781"
            },
            {
              "payload": "0x01",
              "validatorIndex": "7",
              "signature": "0xbcf8cdc9c1e0ffc417894a1ebdcfd0c58ddf21cc97430649543425c5cd3b2e71fabdbc06a4356879c069815e2d898c8ab26818a4adeca906d8e4038ef3a6218e"
            },
            {
              "payload": "0x00",
              "validatorIndex": "8",
              "signature": "0x7eac3420449f9b0197fdb506e9313033f5672c9b3c1658e7f34362e97c1e5a04ec72b7b365a020a0319af6df917d56e92cc8869994dc7e18c6ceb1e049010d8e"
            },
            {
              "payload": "0x01",
              "validatorIndex": "9",
              "signature": "0xb6f5ba83a56e2bd546560ce0ebec749e67fecd38a62f68e4d2aa5f7bc49bff185ef03a1fbc5f58dde5763bc285d4cc8fbe069511ee7658e44dedae72d77f9d8f"
            },
            {
              "payload": "0x01",
              "validatorIndex": "10",
              "signature": "0x7e5dc1a59a1ddb519f467232296658326401f05821c17e3f351ffc89864577374b2dc42bf3602a4213c66385663d23d55333a6c603fc942e2fbbc21f2cef4a81"
            },
            {
              "payload": "0x01",
              "validatorIndex": "11",
              "signature": "0x46a836622c957f3269466200e1750c9c24da195182f3e92aaf36c8157ac6e13e2cfa0bb7a4546020a83769e3683ac544c315cb76e59f86d342c7569c2a9b868e"
            },
            {
              "payload": "0x01",
              "validatorIndex": "12",
              "signature": "0x4217a8df37018bc9f087779367cb28e210c85bf7a55997f3059f57949c02e51c49c19d259b0b74991bab1d737f79db304c67ba0333f8842e793dbbbaa8d11383"
            },
            {
              "payload": "0x01",
              "validatorIndex": "13",
              "signature": "0xde7560d7c65d596ead8b5f186ac52e71df819aacd30746ca580cb1fdbb12021de5681f142f2963300d2aabfc71923b3bce6a2710977fd68153ab4e83f1ebeb8e"
            },
            {
              "payload": "0x01",
              "validatorIndex": "14",
              "signature": "0x42718adc45175d4078571d0997e4bba78982eebb19e1c09c162660fbe97dc352bf0c22831cd3c71acd33912078272ad746d766b61c3782690ac6a993751c058e"
            },
            {
              "payload": "0x01",
              "validatorIndex": "15",
              "signature": "0xe0caa22eaadb4e6adc5db0519970ba580d74fb41ee1cb257a098f3ff5a115b3066ca07740d98bcc0a781734b171e8c7f6d4d15d3864cb257f0834fb2e79d978d"
            }
          ],
          "backedCandidates": [],
          "disputes": [],
          "parentHeader": {
            "parentHash": "0xe4fb4a86c133cb54c03c0ec3ecc0b9a1f5a0754a1c54e558c8d1190638f6a516",
            "number": "10481440",
            "stateRoot": "0x1cd0b9bc1bec46f8a037406a634643cfaa70594dacd41c175a34ccd2007a8570",
            "extrinsicsRoot": "0xbd09b840395f86294aa58a02eb533a1c357ce0e101f040cd8308416feac82840",
            "digest": {
              "logs": [
                {
                  "preRuntime": [
                    "0x42414245",
                    "0x0302000000b21e65100000000070a407cf426a2d4be76a470c1a55543b5a04821e164aa880f591ba81b68586749d5c0f4ecec95f09e90036aa4253539170f6cc867175b3dc909254fe0bf30109b3434be0361bb8eb9d8128b3070c6a7d19136684998c4a17d0145d6f9e91bd06"
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "seal": [
                    "0x42414245",
                    "0xce959e689ad99b04e4b698d8c6d8fc1e71c83160cad8e9f2272a8ea58ce2862c8487cc08d007daba92b35fa47fc063bb770855edecaae7b16b0876e26afbca83"
                  ]
                }
              ]
            }
          }
        }
      },
      "tip": null,
      "hash": "0x7716033e0de706f5161c666738885f8d547c28856356a01a02873c1ac5117b91",
      "info": {},
      "era": {
        "immortalEra": "0x00"
      },
      "events": [
        {
          "method": {
            "pallet": "paraInclusion",
            "method": "CandidateIncluded"
          },
          "data": [
            {
              "descriptor": {
                "paraId": "1000",
                "relayParent": "0xe4fb4a86c133cb54c03c0ec3ecc0b9a1f5a0754a1c54e558c8d1190638f6a516",
                "collator": "0x8a6a92e1ad157bdd583aeefad2d57cfbe2050a599148017e1498918c86bd9849",
                "persistedValidationDataHash": "0xfe2948170db46f4feed4afbfbd7bb39f5d0e41a16c0833a7a08a7178af15a239",
                "povHash": "0xddb42fa20ac2204fee612090ba6c1e7192f4fc1b58cb4450d1a9179025bd2720",
                "erasureRoot": "0x14965df4c560cb36db91e3e6de25d3d9e02f6a11e26cc7aac413baea7db79ab3",
                "signature": "0x261b227b55ed8f88f3968d1b40942939084f42ca73581b3212c877e73b51e90656372a1dfad1acfbc00c8746e4b4043bcaccdda65cb2e9c58155bad973f1fe8d",
                "paraHead": "0x9ce5ff3571ab2ad393f0fe35375629146f05a77c059decbe9967dbdfe1da4ce5",
                "validationCodeHash": "0x2b310e37351c1cc9dc8adc2c932c14d5b304495ad9e25958d8466a6a50e70907"
              },
              "commitmentsHash": "0x1d1b3cfd72651083ccf419cba59c8c878e8384897d80fe0bcc3f13becf1b1328"
            },
            "0xd676238ebe72c47096f59c7d47f0c26bbd114000fd2986fdc8df88e5df06bbeede4b7900840dc2b4b8e712d8ad73ce14f445ba5fbc5b5216dbdff01eb1328ae640a75f6abe7fd55f123bd8835ddd77fe8ed42db5017651c4a5c6bbfe4c3b2d7fd6b8124508066175726120588f320800000000056175726101017efd693a4032ed4ef1fc78b424563ebf07d1736090ee1a64fc92f516ea1b29012a8ec74b731d077a08afd5100ba40e7ff515de47ee0eae2ec932ce26ad9f6882",
            "0",
            "0"
          ]
        },
        {
          "method": {
            "pallet": "system",
            "method": "ExtrinsicSuccess"
          },
          "data": [
            {
              "weight": "43822528000",
              "class": "Mandatory",
              "paysFee": "Yes"
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "success": true,
      "paysFee": false
    },
    {
      "method": {
        "pallet": "balances",
        "method": "transferKeepAlive"
      },
      "signature": {
        "signature": "0xc6b7056d878619196516853d3f3e1b72ea9091652365bb7db76a4ba21e6857011bb459d00148be7fc022d49aad7f1237114ad5d78ac0b4c3a5421bbcbe3a2106",
        "signer": {
          "id": "5DMARAukVR38V2dpRja9yxgHuAdxjt6AgctJTezGyL3DXt1G"
        }
      },
      "nonce": "6",
      "args": {
        "dest": {
          "id": "5Fdco1gcXmHQbcGuPrsfT5h8twXwH4kpdWkJq7Fafrgcuvzm"
        },
        "value": "2000000000000"
      },
      "tip": "0",
      "hash": "0x8e87c35a184bbd60576a8ea127e98c96b147d921123e1a0005b254f37c89997c",
      "info": {
        "error": "Fee calculation not supported for 9190#westend"
      },
      "era": {
        "mortalEra": [
          "64",
          "27"
        ]
      },
      "events": [
        {
          "method": {
            "pallet": "balances",
            "method": "Withdraw"
          },
          "data": [
            "5DMARAukVR38V2dpRja9yxgHuAdxjt6AgctJTezGyL3DXt1G",
            "15700002046"
          ]
        },
        {
          "method": {
            "pallet": "system",
            "method": "NewAccount"
          },
          "data": [
            "5Fdco1gcXmHQbcGuPrsfT5h8twXwH4kpdWkJq7Fafrgcuvzm"
          ]
        },
        {
          "method": {
            "pallet": "balances",
            "method": "Endowed"
          },
          "data": [
            "5Fdco1gcXmHQbcGuPrsfT5h8twXwH4kpdWkJq7Fafrgcuvzm",
            "2000000000000"
          ]
        },
        {
          "method": {
            "pallet": "balances",
            "method": "Transfer"
          },
          "data": [
            "5DMARAukVR38V2dpRja9yxgHuAdxjt6AgctJTezGyL3DXt1G",
            "5Fdco1gcXmHQbcGuPrsfT5h8twXwH4kpdWkJq7Fafrgcuvzm",
            "2000000000000"
          ]
        },
        {
          "method": {
            "pallet": "balances",
            "method": "Deposit"
          },
          "data": [
            "5Ft3J6iqSQPWX2S9jERXcMpevt8JDUPWjec5uGierfVGXisE",
            "15700002046"
          ]
        },
        {
          "method": {
            "pallet": "system",
            "method": "ExtrinsicSuccess"
          },
          "data": [
            {
              "weight": "148670000",
              "class": "Normal",
              "paysFee": "Yes"
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "success": true,
      "paysFee": true
    }
  ],
  "onFinalize": {
    "events": []
  },
  "finalized": true
}

[TarikGul]

Hey @lcovar , much thanks for reporting this issue.

After looking into it, the problem revolves around the fact the the TransactionByteFee was removed in 9190. The code that handles this can be found here.

Currently looking into solutions that will get this fixed as soon as I can. It is a little tricky in the sense that our Rust package @substrate/calc which is native to sidecar has a lot of logic that is dependent on the TransactionByteFee so we will need to maintain the integrity of historic runtimes while also adjusting for the current update.

Edit: It wasn't removed just changed into lengthToFee, I'll have a fix out shortly, once merged we will release a new version

[lcovar]

Thanks @TarikGul for looking into this so quickly.

[mcalcano-bg]

This is not as important, but I get similar errors when retrieving really old blocks, for example: 1191, 1197, 1238, 1240, 2549, 258695, 285763, 311297, 311308, 326958. In these cases it references runtime versions 1 and 4. I am wondering if that is something you would want to fix at some point even though the issue is for old blocks?

[TarikGul]

This is not as important, but I get similar errors when retrieving really old blocks, for example: 1191, 1197, 1238, 1240, 2549, 258695, 285763, 311297, 311308, 326958. In these cases it references runtime versions 1 and 4. I am wondering if that is something you would want to fix at some point even though the issue is for old blocks?

@mcalcano-bg Yea I can double check those blocks for you, sidecar should have complete support of all historic runtimes (Or atleast we try our best), so if its not working correctly for some runtimes I am more than happy to fix it. That being said, if my memory serves me correctly there when I worked on this a while ago that there were some runtimes from the very start for kusama and westend that didnt actually have fees. I'll have to double check though but either way it wouldn't hurt to document.