More builtin custom replacements

[sindresorhus]

For popular things that makes sense. Suggestions welcome, but I'm not going to add more than maybe 30. So make it worth it.

Don't do a PR. I'll add them all at once when we've decided on what to include.

[idleberg]

German umlauts (ä, ö, ü) and the letter ß (“sharp s”) are commonly replaced differently:

ä -> ae
ö -> oe
ü -> ue
ß -> ss

So maybe an option for these cases makes sense. If I'm not mistaken the ß is replaced as sz in Switzerland.

Other characters for special treament could be @ and %.

[sindresorhus]

So maybe an option for these cases makes sense. If I'm not mistaken the ß is replaced as sz in Switzerland.

I don't intend to internationalize this module, so the target is English.

Other characters for special treament could be @ and %.

👍

[CanRau]

Just out of curiosity as I'm a little bit confused about slug styles in general^^
What's the reason behind not supporting i18n?
I think it's important and as shown in the example by @idleberg replacing an ä with a doesn't really make sense in the resulting word to a german user.
So again, just asking, trying to form a picture of URL slugs and reasonings behind their various possible designs 😉 😁

[sindresorhus]

@CanRau Unicode slugs can be fine. It really depends on your constraints, both company-wise and tech stack wise. I'm happy to add an option to preserve Unicode characters. It's just not a common request.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_URL#Slug

[CanRau]

Hum, now I'm pretty confused and I think the conversation might be confused, too 😅
I thought, for whatever reason, that slugify (this module here) replaces ä-> a but according to replacements.js#L6 it already does the right thing 😳I might've installed npm.im/slugify instead of @sindresorhus/slugify 🤣 what a shame. Now that I tried (again), that's the most likely^^

So german umlauts are properly replaced already and you don't intent to add support for the swiss variation in ß, that makes sense, if that's what you were saying. haha finally 👍

I suffered for nothing 😆 Then I believe (it seems) only #37 would be missing for @sindresorhus/slugify to be the perfect slugger for me ❤️ 🤞

[sindresorhus]

So german umlauts are properly replaced already and you don't intent to add support for the swiss variation in ß, that makes sense, if that's what you were saying. haha finally 👍

See my comment in #38 (comment).

[Haraldson]

I think a common expectation is to have non-alphanumerical symbols map to an empty string by default. Consider for instance a business name like Daisy’s Diner – I don’t want daisy-s-diner as my slug, but rather daisys-diner.

(I half-expected each array in customReplacements to be applied directly to String.replace, but was unsuccessful in passing a regular expression as the first argument. If I could do [/\W/, ''], much would be solved.)

[sindresorhus]

I think a common expectation is to have non-alphanumerical symbols map to an empty string by default. Consider for instance a business name like Daisy’s Diner – I don’t want daisy-s-diner as my slug, but rather daisys-diner.

I agree with your specific example, but not that all non-alphanumerical symbols should be empty strings. Open a new issue with this and we can figure out a way to improve the output.

[deadcoder0904]

@sindresorhus What do you think about removing filler words for better SEO? See https://www.reliablesoft.net/slug/

Read https://twitter.com/deadcoder0904/status/1424627186565193734 for TL;DR

Or should this be done manually? (which makes more sense tbf)

[fannarsh]

It would be nice to have em dash — replaced by a regular -.
In many fonts there are hardly a visible difference which contributes to many copy paste "issues" from word processors.

[CanRau]

Don't have any experience regarding em-dash though it sounds interesting 👏🏼

[fannarsh]

My comment was actually meant for the transliterate repo, but for some reason I mixed it up 🤷
That being said, I'm assuming that this sindresorhus/transliterate#11 would take care of my suggestion.

[CanRau]

Uh yea I see, so seems that issue got kinda forgotten

[aegatlin]

Regarding @Haraldson 's comment on daisy's diner becoming daisys-diner instead of daisy-s-diner, I have an open PR for that in particular, #71 , just fyi for people in this thread.