Three listings for Accessible UK Train Timetables, traintimes.org.uk

[grahamperrin]

1. https://pwa-directory.appspot.com/pwas/5128878007779328 re: https://traintimes.org.uk/h
2. https://pwa-directory.appspot.com/pwas/5630437284642816 re: https://traintimes.org.uk/h
3. https://pwa-directory.appspot.com/pwas/5678982740049920 re: https://traintimes.org.uk/Runcorn/Euston/15:15/today (amusingly specific).

I suggest a single listing with reference to:

• https://traintimes.org.uk/

[andreban]

This is due to traintimes using different manifest URL and start_urls for each URL on their site, which makes it tricky to uniquely identify a PWA (see #493, w3c/manifest#586 and w3c/manifest#668)

This could be something a website does intentionally, but looks like a bug in this case. We should keep the older record (the first one) and delete 5630437284642816 and 5678982740049920)

/cc @juliantoledo

[PaulKinlan]

It's not a bug, they let you have a custom pwa per train route. I use it this way.

…

On Fri, Jul 13, 2018, 09:23 André Cipriani Bandarra < ***@***.***> wrote: This is due to traintimes using different manifest URL and start_urls for each URL on their site, which makes it tricky to uniquely identify a PWA (see #493 <#493>, w3c/manifest#586 <w3c/manifest#586> and w3c/manifest#668 <w3c/manifest#668>) This could be something a website does intentionally, but looks like a bug in this case. We keep the older record (the first one) and delete 5630437284642816 and 5678982740049920) /cc @juliantoledo <https://github.com/juliantoledo> — You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#505 (comment)>, or mute the thread <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AACxxmvoUhPvJo4xcYB8c13Ym4L9TKuOks5uGFjmgaJpZM4VNYsW> .

[PaulKinlan]

I'll be pushing a lot of developers to think about these bespoke pwas a lot so id suggest a better solution that deleting them :)

…

On Fri, Jul 13, 2018, 09:49 Paul Kinlan ***@***.***> wrote: It's not a bug, they let you have a custom pwa per train route. I use it this way. On Fri, Jul 13, 2018, 09:23 André Cipriani Bandarra < ***@***.***> wrote: > This is due to traintimes using different manifest URL and start_urls for > each URL on their site, which makes it tricky to uniquely identify a PWA > (see #493 <#493>, > w3c/manifest#586 <w3c/manifest#586> and > w3c/manifest#668 <w3c/manifest#668>) > > This could be something a website does intentionally, but looks like a > bug in this case. We keep the older record (the first one) and delete > 5630437284642816 and 5678982740049920) > > /cc @juliantoledo <https://github.com/juliantoledo> > > — > You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. > Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub > <#505 (comment)>, > or mute the thread > <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AACxxmvoUhPvJo4xcYB8c13Ym4L9TKuOks5uGFjmgaJpZM4VNYsW> > . >

[andreban]

I considered that might be intentional, but since they actually have a PWA per route / day / departure time, I thought not.

For instance, https://traintimes.org.uk/Runcorn/Euston/09:04a/today has a different manifest and start_url than https://traintimes.org.uk/Runcorn/Euston/15:15/today, which is also different from https://traintimes.org.uk/Runcorn/Euston/09:04a/2018-07-13

We could group those apps by origin, but then 2 completely different PWAs under the same domain would count as a single app.

[fstanis]

2 completely different PWAs under the same domain

That sounds like it's potentially more of a niche case than two related apps under the same domain, no?

[juliantoledo]

Ideally, we should group them under a single entry, but it would be a bit difficult to compare them to know they are the "same" PWA with multiple entries.