Removed totalDifficulty from Blockschema

[Giulio2002]

Context

With Ethereum's transition from Proof of Work (PoW) to Proof of Stake (PoS) through the Ethereum 2.0 upgrade, the role of certain fields in the blockchain's schema has fundamentally changed. Specifically, the totalDifficulty field, which played a crucial role in chain selection and synchronization under PoW, is no longer relevant in the PoS consensus mechanism.

Motivation

1. Obsolescence in PoS

   • Under PoW, totalDifficulty was essential for determining the canonical chain by identifying the chain with the highest cumulative difficulty. This metric was critical for chain selection and block validation.
   • In Ethereum's current PoS consensus, chain selection and block validation mechanisms are entirely different. The concept of "difficulty" has been replaced with more relevant metrics. Therefore, totalDifficulty no longer plays any role in the core protocol's operation.

2. Redundancy in JSON-RPC

   • Maintaining totalDifficulty in the Block schema within the JSON-RPC interface introduces unnecessary redundancy. Since the field is no longer required for synchronization, verification, or any critical protocol operations, its presence serves no practical purpose.
   • Keeping this field in the JSON-RPC could be considered code debt—a remnant from the PoW era that no longer aligns with the current PoS consensus.

3. Opportunities for Refactoring

   • By allowing clients to omit the totalDifficulty field from the JSON-RPC, client teams can gradually remove dependencies on outdated concepts. This opens the door to cleaner, more efficient codebases that are easier to maintain and extend.
   • Removing this field would streamline the block schema, reducing the cognitive load for developers and decreasing the risk of maintaining legacy code that does not contribute to the current protocol's functioning.

Current usage in application

For as far as I was able to gather (I still need to get more input on this), the 2 places were totalDifficulty is useful in the jsonrpc are:

• Block Explorers
• Transition hive tests

Block explorers

Although totalDifficulty is used by block explorers, it is probably not so useful information to display. Additionally, Block explorers do not directly query the node but create their own indexing from the json RPC. Therefore, creating a new indexing for totalDifficulty should be trivial if it is deemed of critical importance.

Transition hive tests

the totalDifficulty field is checked in hive tests for engine api transition but such check is mostly something extra and can be safely removed (albeit it will reduce the insights of merge transition).

[g11tech]

lgtm from ethereumjs

[onbjerg]

lgtu from reth

[garyschulte]

Besu still supports PoW (for ETC for example). It would be less than ideal to have to have chain-specific rpc header response formats, but it would not be the end of the world if the rest of the EL clients signal they would prefer to drop total difficulty.

[GIgako19929]

``

[GIgako19929]

---